282 Comments
User's avatar
Stephen Brady's avatar

At this point, other than aggregation, I don't see what they have to offer over and above Substack... Mastodon is balky at best. I consider it read-only. I have never figured out how to post there. I read George Takei, but that is all and if he moved over here, I would be much happier. Disqus has never gotten any better and I would be just as happy if JoeMyGod moved over here as well. I have never been on Facebook or Xitter. JoeMyGod still posts a lot of potentially interesting stuff he finds on Xitter, but I refuse to click on them because I so detest Melon Musk.

Expand full comment
oraxx's avatar

Few web sites ever disappointed me more than Only Sky. Some good contributors, including our wonderful host on this site, but a terrible commenting system. The commenting community is as important as the articles for a site dealing with ideas. I wish them well, but I don't have a lot of confidence they will pull it off if the same person is in charge.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

Someone talked about the relaunch a few days ago. It seems you have to pay if you want to comment. Sans moi.

Expand full comment
Joan the Dork's avatar

Asking for commenters to pay up front, on a site that's relaunching after a catastrophic failure by mismanagement, is... a 𝘣𝘪𝘵 audacious.

Expand full comment
cdbunch's avatar

I think their hearts may be in the right place, but they didn't and still don't have an actual business plan to keep them afloat, so they're trying anything they can think of to generate an income stream, no matter how idiotic.

Expand full comment
Joan the Dork's avatar

The head-scratcher here is that it's entirely possible to limit free accounts to reading X number of articles, or posting Y number of comments per day (or a character limit, or access to more features like formatting, links, images, etc); those would be perfectly tolerable options.

As-is, better than half the articles I see on the new site are locked behind a paywall, and even a goodly chunk of those are reposts from the previous version of OS which in some cases are two years old. That's not exactly what I'd call rolling out the red carpet to attract new readers; most passers-by are not going to create an account, much less upgrade to a paid membership, just to see what the place has to offer- and they aren't going to lure many people back who abandoned the old site, either. There's no bait on the hook.

Expand full comment
oraxx's avatar

It doesn't sound as if they learned much from their failure. I will never pay to comment.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

If I were to pay, I would give the money to the author, not the hosting site.

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

Yep, it is pay to play.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

I have nothing against it, if the content worth it.

Expand full comment
maddog7's avatar

i payed on the prev OS .. ie,

I commented, they kicked me off <sigh>

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

Let us not forget their extreme arrogance and condescending treatment of us.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

For all its faults Substack comment system doesn't impose a time limit on editing.

Expand full comment
XJC's avatar

Christians or OnlySky?

Expand full comment
Maltnothops's avatar

Obligatory: why not both?

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

OnlyShit.

Expand full comment
Troublesh00ter's avatar

Shall we mention that gymnasts have been doing the Iron Cross for longer than I've been alive (and that's 73 years and some!)?

Seems I just did.

Expand full comment
Daniel Rotter's avatar

Fitting, in a way, since it takes a lot of mental, um, gymnastics to believe in Christianity.

Expand full comment
larry parker's avatar

"OnlySky relaunches with a focus on the future"

Yeah, they don't want to talk about the past...

Expand full comment
maddog7's avatar

on their site it says .. 'same mission'. Beware

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Why, that's not ominous at all...

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Or Bruno.

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Isn't a dwarf planet still a planet? ;)

Expand full comment
Matri's avatar

It orbits a star instead of another planet. That’s literally what a planet is.

That’s why Endor is called a moon.

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Pluto oddball orbit, both tilted and elliptical, takes it around the Sun every 248 years. :D

Expand full comment
Matri's avatar

Well it’s obviously not caught in Venus’s gravitational field now, is it?

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

It's a Kuiper belt object.

Expand full comment
Guerillasurgeon's avatar

So they expect to be successful now you have to pay to comment? When they couldn't be successful with free commenting. Well fingers crossed I guess.

Expand full comment
larry parker's avatar

They should try selling ad space to christian wingnuts. /s

Expand full comment
Guerillasurgeon's avatar

Christian wing nuts were the reason they had to leave Patheos. They couldn't handle the criticism of Christianity. I'm not sure if other religions contributed, given that Christianity was the main one criticised. :)

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

There was some Pagan blogs, not sure if they are still there.

Expand full comment
Lynn Veit's avatar

Is that why Patheos wouldn't allow any more criticizing of Christianity? Because of Christian whining? (I'm a little out of the loop -- all I knew was R2D wasn't there anymore and I had to go find it.)

Now that I'm out of the cult, I am continually amazed at how touchy and thin-skinned they are. Those who supposedly have The Almighty at their backs.

Expand full comment
Lynn Veit's avatar

I wish them luck as well. The more atheist sites there are, the better. Zeus knows how flooded the internet is with christer crap.

Expand full comment
Lynn Veit's avatar

Whenever there's a Pride parade in NYC, there's a tornado in Tuscaloosa. God is not mocked.

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

From what he says in the article, it doesn't sound like Hemant is thinking of returning to OS. Praise be the FSM if that's so. I hope he decides to pass on re-upping.

Expand full comment
Troublesh00ter's avatar

I sincerely hope he stays HERE. I'm not made of money, and paying to comment rubs me the wrong way as it is, never mind having to switch platforms AGAIN.

Substack WORKS, insofar as I'm concerned. Can we just stay here? Please?

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Big "Hell, yes!" on all of that. You don't fix what ain't broke.

Expand full comment
cdbunch's avatar

I still miss memes and videos*, and though I've gotten used to it, the threading leaves much to be desired.

*The weird thing is it works in the reply window on the Activities page, but disappears when actually posted. So Substack knows how to do it, but doesn't

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

I miss bold/italic/underscore/strikethrough/spoiler tags etc. Not to mention special characters and the like.

Expand full comment
cdbunch's avatar

Those work too on the Activity page, but not when posted.

Expand full comment
Matri's avatar

It really says a lot about OnlySky when we PREFER SubStack to OS…

Expand full comment
cdbunch's avatar

OnlySky is a nice idea. But it appears to be run by writers who have no idea how to run and market a self-sustaining blog site, much less one that turns a profit for its contributors.

Expand full comment
Whitney's avatar

From where I sit, they need Hemant more than Hemant needs them. That isn't exactly a reason to switch, now is it?

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

Lettuce 🙏

Expand full comment
maddog7's avatar

he is not listed under Authors, so there is hope he will pass

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

En un mot comme en cent 🖕

If Hemant change his mind and go there, like I said to Oraxx, ça sera sans moi.

Expand full comment
Kay-El's avatar

I’ll pass. I only pay to comment on one site. The other subscriptions I have do not require payment to comment but some I pay for because I think their writing is worth the support.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

Trust the comments from those who knew the first os, you definitely don't want to go there, unless they made a 180° but they are more prone to a 360.

Expand full comment
Kay-El's avatar

Exactly. That’s why I’m passing.

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

I was glad to subscribe to FA @ Substack. Value for money.

OS? With all their screw-ups (Viafoura, anyone?) and cavalier attitude towards the commenters? Sorry. Fool me once...

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

I called it "va t'faire foutre*".

* Go fuck yourself.

Expand full comment
maddog7's avatar

gonna write that down :-)

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

I preferred "ViaShit."

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

That works too.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

N'est-ce pas ? 😁

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Speaking of subscriptions:

Why am I being asked to subscribe when I already have? I used to have a little checkmark with the word "Subscribed." Not anymore.

Expand full comment
Hemant Mehta's avatar

Just saw this comment. Feel free to email me if this is more than some temporary glitch and I'll check it out.

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Will do.

(I noticed it a week ago as of this date)

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

No sé.

Can't you switch to his Patreon ?

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

It just seems to be a computer glitch of some sort. Even my little "Subscibed" icon disappeared.

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

Me too.

Expand full comment
NOGODZ20's avatar

Can't be expired. Hemant would send me an email to tell me so, like he did before. I subscribed fairly recently.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

OT : 2 yogurts (a 3rd at the ready), 1 apple sauce, 4 squares of chocolate (🤮), 1 "chicken" cutlet, 2 slices of multigrain bread. All that since 12:30 pm and my fucking glycemia still struggle to go above .80. What do I have to do ? Swallow sugar directly from the box ? 🤬

Expand full comment
Troublesh00ter's avatar

Eat a jelly donut! 😁

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

It would be difficult, I wasn't born yet.

Expand full comment
Bill Wilson's avatar

The Cracker Jack, still, abides.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

Can you send me some ? At worst, DM can have them.

BHm, somewhere near Paris, France.

Merci d'avance.

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

There is always divinity.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

I keep the pecans, you can have the rest. Starting with the eggs white 😝

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

You say that if it is a problem.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

Did you saw the picture in my email ? Since then my glycemia dropped to .54, again. I took the screesnshot about 30 minutes ago... I am in the red right now. I should be in the green (.80 to 1.79).

Expand full comment
cdbunch's avatar

When I used to have a lot of low blood sugar episodes, I found rice-krispie treats were good at stabilizing my blood sugar. Peanut butter was also good.

Glucerna is supposed to be made for exactly this, but I don't know if they have a vegan option.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

Since my last comment, I ate a banana, more yogurt, some vegan cookies stolen from DM' stash. Still the same. I am at a loss here. I am used to theses kind of bad days every few weeks but it was not as bad as today is.

Expand full comment
cdbunch's avatar

I would definitely call my doctor in the morning and I might consider going to the ER where they can monitor it and maybe figure out what is going on.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

It's going up again. Probably the combination of a broth with a high sugar content and the furikake.

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

I can't. DM's chemo day tomorrow.

I am trying a tteokbokki with some furikake in the hopes it works.

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

Oh, and they have members only "articles."

Expand full comment
Troublesh00ter's avatar

Sounds awfully nose-stuck-in-the-air to me. I'd as soon PASS, thankuverymuch.

Expand full comment
Matri's avatar

*coughs*bullshit*coughs*

I’ll believe it when I see it. Especially if their mod teams are just as big assholes as they were in the past.

And I don’t mean the AI moderator.

Expand full comment
wreck's avatar

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, you can't get fooled again.

Expand full comment
larry parker's avatar

Don't beat around the Bush, WHO said that. ; )

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

𝘉𝘢𝘣𝘢 𝘖'𝘙𝘪𝘭𝘦𝘺

Expand full comment
larry parker's avatar

I thought they were deaf, dumb and blind.

Expand full comment
Zorginipsoundsor's avatar

Never the less, he 𝘚𝘶𝘳𝘦 𝘱𝘭𝘢𝘺𝘴 𝘢 𝘮𝘦𝘢𝘯 𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘣𝘢𝘭𝘭.

Expand full comment
Troublesh00ter's avatar

Frankly, I wasn't wild for OnlySky for its overly sensitive nannies and learning to work around them, however much that was possible. Neither OnlySky nor Substack have any facility for text modification or graphics, and I wish at least one of them did, but given a choice, I think I would prefer to see the Hemant and the Friendly Atheist stick with Substack.

We've been through enough changes. Can we be consistent for at least a little while?

Expand full comment
Black Hole and DM mourner's avatar

Remember what happened to maddog7 when trolls where allowed to stay because "opinions".

Expand full comment
maddog7's avatar

yes, I remember what happened to -me- him LoL

Hope Hemant stays away from OS. I like the gang here and the ability to be snarky and irreverant.

Expand full comment
Troublesh00ter's avatar

Vaguely. As it comes to alternative opinions, I don't mind them ... IF they're thought through and have some solid ground to stand on.

Sadly, there hasn't been a whole lot of credible alternative opinions out there lately.

Expand full comment
larry parker's avatar

OT: There has been a trend for the last couple of years for sports broadcasters to go to split screen for commercials. That way fans won't miss any of the action and the network still gets paid for the commercial. Well, NBC just did that during the gymnastics competition except the coverage is on tape delay. Who are they trying to fool?

Expand full comment
Joan the Dork's avatar

It's 𝘢𝘭𝘮𝘰𝘴𝘵 as if somebody realized that people hate having their entertainment interrupted by advertising! Who'da thunk it?!

Expand full comment