Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Freelance Historian's avatar

I am a professional historian who focuses on the World Wars and have taught seminars on the history of the Holocaust, and one of the sections deals with the Church during the war and its complicity. It's a mixed bag, and like all things complicated. Early on, when news of the Nazi T-4 "euthenasia" program of medical extermination of "useless eaters" and "those with lives not worth living (AKA the mentally ill, developmentally disabled, and the like) broke in 1941, It was Cardinal Clemens August Graf von Galen gave a series of sermons and wrote a prominent public letter protesting against it on moral grounds and led a widespread movement against T-4, to the point where the Nazis backed off and pretended to end it in the face of public objection (they of course continued to do so on a smaller scale behind the scenes and fed it all into the extermination camps once those got going full scale in 1942).

This demonstrates a number of things, not all of them complimentary to the Church. Firstly, that there were Church leaders willing to stand against the regime under certain circumstances, and with enough strength to succeed. However, it also shows us something more disturbing when we consider von Galen was subsequently asked to speak out on the similar fate being doled out to Jewish Germans, he did not. You could argue he knew he had pushed his luck far enough already, and there is some inconclusive evidence the Nazis were planning on punishing him once the war was over, but he had succeeded in leading one successful movement against Nazi policy once, and regardless the Church always claims (I know, I know) to champion moral behavior and fearless protection of human dignity so "I feared doing the right thing would get me in trouble" strikes me as a weak defense.

There is another aspect that complicates the Church's relationship with the Nazi state and the Holocaust I feel I should mention here, as it doesn't come up in your post and I believe it is quite relevant. During the last days of the Reich and in its immediate aftermath, any number of war criminals saw the writing on the wall and decided to flee Europe. There were a number of ratlines the Nazis had set up previously, ODESSA being probably the best known, but a number of them ran right through the Vatican. More specifically, Cardinal Luigi Maglione had established a "Catholic refugee" channel with Argentina at Pius XII's request to funnel fleeing Nazis out through both Portugal and Fascist Spain. Bishop Alois Hund and Father Krunoslav Stjepan Draganović both also set up networks to get fleeing Nazis false papers and exit visas to escape, mostly to South America. In these cases, among others, this was done within the overarching auspices of the broader Catholic Church, not just because of pro-Nazi sympathies of this or that Catholic official but also as it aligned with traditional anti-Semitism that existed within Catholic (and other Christian) traditions and the Church's fear of communism; ever since the 1917 revolutions, the Church had viewed the Soviets to be a far greater threat than any of the fascist powers, both because they were openly pro-atheist (though uneven in enforcing it in practice), and more importantly because as socialists they threatened to confiscate Church property should they ever gain power outside of the USSR.

Anyway, this is just scratching the surface of the Church's complicated, often compromised history during the war and in relation to the Holocaust. I would be remiss not to also mention a number of individual priests did speak out on their own initiative and a small number of them were annoying enough to the regime to get themselves thrown in the camps, though despite what the Church would claim after the war they had not been locked up for their faith so much as inconveniencing the Reich. A couple good initial reads on the subject should you wish to go further would be Kevin Spicer's Hitler's Priests: Catholic Clergy and National Socialism and Michael Phayers's The Catholic Church and the Holocaust, 1930 - 1965.

Expand full comment
oraxx's avatar

By any reasonable standard, Pius XII was a monster. He exchanged birthday greetings with Hitler, and never excommunicated him. Many of the top Nazis were Catholic and the only one Pius booted was Joseph Goebbels for the unforgivable sin of marrying a divorced Protestant. The Holocaust wasn't the only horror he ignored by a long shot. He had to be fully aware of the systematic sexual abuse of children at the hands of the priests he chose to protect instead of the victims of their abuse. The residential schools in the US and Canada, and all the horrors perpetrated by the clergy in Ireland. The list goes on and on.

Expand full comment
154 more comments...

No posts