489 Comments

At the end of the day, a church winds up with public money in their coffers, and that makes this wrong. I can't believe this church is the only possible venue available for a graduation.

Expand full comment

"We welcome everyone"

We welcome everyone's money. Fixed it.

Expand full comment

You tell who they welcome by who they *spend* money on, not who they *take* money from.

Expand full comment

***Welcome dependent upon receipt of valid currency and/or check clearing.

Expand full comment

It's the only possible venue for the Christian Nationalists on the school board. Because jeebus.

Expand full comment

Christian Nationalism, I've been seeing that more recently. I think it's a good fit, they just need jackboots.

Expand full comment

I'd be curious to know HOW MUCH money. The article doesn't say.

Expand full comment

"The school district rents the space for about $28,000 each year—including security and traffic control costs—and it’s strictly business."

Expand full comment
founding

I'm impressed and grateful to this young man and to so many of his generation for their ethics and for their courage to stand up against oppression.

"'We welcome everyone,' [Pastor Troy Dobbs] wrote."

Okay, you welcome LGBTQ+ people to sit in church quietly and give you their money while you slander and condemn them.

Do you tell your congregation to welcome them to the neighborhood? To invite them and their same-sex partners over for dinner? To welcome them to the bowling league? The bridge club? The quilting group? To chat pleasantly with them the grocery store?

Do you tell your congregation to do all those and other simple, common decencies, but to always keep thinking that they're HELL-BENT EVIL PEDOPHILE GROOMERS PLOTTING TO TURN EVERY KID IN TOWN GAY?

Is that what you mean by "welcome"?

Your hypocritical religion is welcome to continue its extinction.

Expand full comment

"We welcome everyone."

Translated from Christianese, this comes out "Our church welcomes all denominations, but our favorite is the $20.00 dollar bill."

Expand full comment

Nope, benjamins.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

I was thinking what the max was that pastors might think an average churchgoer could realistically afford to give. :)

Expand full comment

How do you think Creflo Dollar and his ilk get so rich?

Expand full comment

I'm gratified to hear a school board member say "As a district, you listen and if necessary make adjustments" A school board that listens to its students is a rare thing these days.

Expand full comment

"Make adjustments." One could translate that as: "correct an error." Admitting that a mistake was made is easily as rare and as big, possibly bigger ... and VERY refreshing.

Expand full comment

As religion had absolutely nothing to do with these student's education, there's no way on Earth that those students should be graduating from a monument to ignorance and superstition.

Expand full comment

If the school were in West Virginia or Alabama would your opinion change?

Expand full comment

Talking about public schools and how religion plays no part in public school education.

Expand full comment

I don't like the way the church is getting taxpayer dollars, even if at first blush it seems 'reasonable' since they've made efforts to prevent proselytizing. Churches should either support themselves or be forced into bankruptcy so something with more value to the community can use the space/building/resources, public funds should never be used to prop them up.

The above is before we even get to some of the things the church leadership has said about LGBTQ+ folks, divorce, and who knows what else. Churches often claim to welcome those who don't completely align with their views because it means putting butts in the pews (and bucks in the collection plate) in an era where that's becoming more and more difficult to do; that doesn't mean they're not still looking down on specific groups. Just because they allow them to join doesn't mean they're not still effectively second-class members.

Yeah. Mr. Frost is right, it's time to find new location for graduation. This church only represents a slice of the community and graduation is for all the kids, not just a select few.

Expand full comment

“… and graduation is for all the kids, not just a select few.”

Until all public schools go charter, and the religious take over like they do hospitals.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Oklahoma.

Not all public schools will go charter, someone has to teach the underclass just enough to be wage slaves for life.

Expand full comment

Your comment reminds me of a conversation I had with a friend of mine back in Florida when Jeb Bush was governor. We were discussion his wrecking ball approach to all the advances of his Democratic predecessor in the area of preschool and elementary school education programs and safety nets after listening to one of his state-of-the-state speeches, when my friend remarked, "it's almost like he's deliberately trying to create a servant class...an underclass of uneducated poor kids who will be the day-laboring part-time minimum wage adults of the next generation."

Decades later, it's chilling how prescient that comment was.

Expand full comment

And Jeb Bush was considered a 'moderate' in 2016!

Remember Trump's trenchant debate line to him about Jeb's mother?! Stupid 'murica with its 7th grade mentality soaked it up and became immediately enamored with Trump as someone who "tells it like it is."

Expand full comment

¡qǝſ is a moderate compared to DeNazi. So is Darth Voldemort for that matter.

Expand full comment

OT

From "The Guardian" (via MSN) about an hour ago:

"Trump expected to surrender to Miami authorities on Tuesday after indictment."

There's an article, but I merely wanted to post the title. I just like the way it sounds. :)

Expand full comment

I hope to see his perp waddle.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Should he be tried, convicted, sentenced and imprisoned, that orange jumpsuit will work like camouflage.

Expand full comment

Don't celebrate just yet. The judge assigned to his case is Aileen Cannon, the Trump appointee who already tried once to give him a pass in the documents case. Unless the prosecutors find some way to get her booted off the case, I'd say the fix is in. https://www.thenewcivilrightsmovement.com/2023/06/disgraced-trump-appointed-florida-judge-initially-assigned-to-oversee-ex-presidents-criminal-case-report/

Expand full comment

Yeah, Ken Paxton was indicted something like 3 years ago. He's just now, finally facing impeachment, not even a trial on the criminal charges.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

"Don't celebrate just yet."

Spoil-sport. ;)

Expand full comment

You'd think the ethical thing to do under those circumstances would be to recuse oneself.

*sigh*

Expand full comment

Judges and Justices picked by the federalist society, installed by Trump do not know the meaning of the word. Why else do you think they were chosen.

Expand full comment

Surely, you're not naive enough to expect a Trump appointed judge to be ethical? I mean, it may happen, and it may happen that a Republican sex scandal would involve a consenting woman.

Expand full comment

SCOTUS has ruled against Trump a number of times. Including his own picks. :)

Expand full comment

I'm really surprised no one gave me the Leslie Neilson response.

Expand full comment

A leaf out of Clarence Thomas's book?

Expand full comment

Well, she did seek advice from a higher-up. Unfortunately it was Clarence Thomas.

Expand full comment

A new reality show is already in the works: Agent Orange, featuring Teflon Don working his organization from the inside. Co-starring Kellyanne Conway, Mark Meadows, and Michael Flynn.

Expand full comment

Airs on Fox, right?

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Trump Prisons becomes the newest line of Trump-branded products and services rolled out to Trump's 74 million MAGA supporters. It caters to locking up drug dealers from Mexico and 'bad people' without any specific criminal sentences like Hillary Clinton and Hunter Biden.

Expand full comment

I'm with Frost 100% on this business. Grace Church and Troy Dobbs are an atavistic mess of biblical bigotry and should not be allowed to have anything to do with that graduation ceremony.

I would sincerely hope that an alternative venue for those proceedings could be found.

Expand full comment

Grace Church is being sneaky. By landing the public school graduation gig, they think they can claim that the school aligns with their contemptible views.

Public school graduations should never, ever be held at a church of any kind. When I graduated, I graduated at my high school. What a concept, eh?

Expand full comment

My ceremony was held at Red Rocks Amphitheater, which was only 20 minutes away. My oldest graduated last year in the high school field house (aka gymnasium for those outside of Wisconsin) and my daughter just had her 8th grade recognition ceremony in the same place. Like, I just left it a half hour ago.

Chaska is a small town a ways out from most bigger cities, but there are still better places to hold it.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Every time I see a reference to Red Rocks Amphitheater, I'm immediately reminded of the concert New Age musician John Tesh gave there. :)

Expand full comment

I’ve been to a few concerts there, and other events. My brother got married in the chapel there. Or even just went to walk up and down the stairs, lots of folks use it as a workout and there are trails to meander around.

I saw Beck there.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Thanks for giving me an excuse to post this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvtvIcKEQao&pp=ygUbQmVjayAtIFNhdGFuIEdhdmUgTWUgQSBUYWNv

Expand full comment

Google "live at Red Rocks"....lots of various bands and such.

Expand full comment

Yup. But Teshy is the first one I'd ever heard of performing there.

Expand full comment

After I remember my graduation, the first thought for me is U2 at red rocks. They recorded a music video there.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Tesh has a live album from the Red Rocks performance.

The entire concert is on YouTube, but just in case France won't let you see it, here's one of the songs from that show:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WpmNN2l4GOo

Expand full comment

The Moody Blues recorded a live album there. I remember watching it on PBS a few times.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FXXfgWmVAgw

Expand full comment

That sounds awesome. I've been looking for a show to go to there, but I haven't found anything I really want to see.

Expand full comment

I’m going to see Steve Hofstetter in July, but not at Red Rocks, here in Madison.

Expand full comment

Be sure to heckle him. He really likes that. 😉

Expand full comment

My high school graduation was on the football field. It was definitely large enough, as it was designed to hold the entire school, their relatives AND the opposing team's people. Yes, it was May in Arizona but it was held after dark and in addition to the lightweight regalia, most of us wore shorts and t-shirts under them.

Expand full comment

We wore dress slacks and ties (the women of course wore dresses). Shorts were forbidden or I definitely would have worn some. And in Oklahoma, it doesn't cool much at night.

Expand full comment

Even when the wind comes sweepin' down the plain?

Expand full comment

Can't have it outside. May is the middle of storm season. Don't really know until about 4p if it's going to rain.

Expand full comment

Mine, as well. Lots of room. No problem with the weather.

Expand full comment

So did I, in a gym, without air-conditioning, in May, in what is consistently the hottest town in Oklahoma. The only thing anyone remembers about my High School graduation is sweat.

Doesn't mean the church is the best venue or that young Mr. Frost is wrong to be concerned. Just that there may not be reasonable alternatives depending on distance (time) and cost. I mean, think about what even $5,000 could do if spent on the education of the students rather than the graduation ceremony.

Expand full comment

Oklahoma! How do you escape?

Expand full comment

I walked across the "river". Almost got my socks wet. Of course, I only made it as far as south Texas, so it's questionable if I escaped or just went from one room in Hell to another.

Expand full comment

Fifty-five years ago, I graduated in our own high school gymnasium, which was more than capable of handling the crowd. Interestingly, my daughter's HS graduation ceremonies were held at the State Theater in downtown Cleveland (which I'm sure was a considerable buck!). Granted that in a rural area, finding a proper venue could be a daunting problem. That doesn't change the fact that a church such as Grace Church is utterly inappropriate, considering its attitude on critical issues.

Expand full comment

Graduation online is better than graduation in a church.

Expand full comment

Who is this Grace Church woman, anyway?

Expand full comment

I can understand why the schools don’t consider moving to Minneapolis. I grew up near the twin cities and a good friend moved from my town to Chaska in middle school. It was over an hour drive to go visit. It is not a slightly longer drive and the economic status of the Chaska and Chanhassen area, an hour can be difficult to manage.

That is not to say I don’t agree with the student. Definitely find another option, mega churches need to be starved of attention and money, especially tax money. Finding an alternative might be a bit more difficult than represented here, but it is worth it.

Expand full comment

I agree with this student and I also see the need to change the place where they hold this most important ceremony. I'm happy that my school was so small that the school gym (not Jordan FCS) was adequate because it is one of the few times a high school graduate gets public acknowledgement for an accomplishment.

To sully that by adding a church (think how much these "patriots" would scream if it was a Mosque) venue is unnecessary and wrong at every turn.

Expand full comment

I find myself wondering how many of the board members are also members of that church.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Good for that student.

Also, some of my family members are going to some kind of event at grace church in July. It's as unsurprising as it is disgusting.

Edited to add: alright, I broke down and dredged through the church's webshite to find out what they're going to. It's a "Christian wealth creation event" starring tim Tebow, one of the duck dynasty guys, a couple musicians I've never heard of, and a pair of con artists that call themselves "kingdom entrepreneurs".

So...I'm expecting financial disaster in the future of the family. Glad it's not immediate family that's going to the clown show, but I do feel bad for the kids who are going to be effected.

Expand full comment

"In the meantime, graduates who take these concerns seriously can always make sure they’re promoting LGBTQ rights and bodily autonomy and civil rights and everything else this church opposes in whatever symbolic ways they choose during the ceremonies. Even if the building belongs to an evangelical megachurch, it doesn’t mean the graduates need to give the church’s beliefs any respect."

NO!

There have already been stories this spring of schools prohibiting graduates from displaying any personal opinions. No eagle feathers for Native Americans, no orange cords to remember school shooting victims. Public schools don't want to publicly embrace the diversity of their students, despite their public statements. Actions speak louder than words.

We had a similar situation here but with graduation from the police academy. the ceremonies were being held at a local megachurch, despite there being many public venues available.

Expand full comment

Interesting. Our students – used to and probably still do – often wear national costume to prize-giving. Or some variety of national costume/school uniform, because some schools at least allow formal wear for PI students as part of the uniform, which is usually a black lava lava. At the very least it would be negotiable. Maybe not in private schools though.

Expand full comment

I can't comprehend a HS graduation costing $28,000. Maybe it's because my HS class was only 40 people.

Expand full comment

My HS graduation ceremony cost 0 €.

Expand full comment

Mine cost 0 €, too. : )

Expand full comment

You are an unconscionable smartass, Larry, and you need to stop. That's MY job, dammit.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023·edited Jun 9, 2023

Scram, buddy. You're workin' MY side o' the street.

Expand full comment

Boys, Boys, don't worry, there's enough work for all three of you. No one's in danger of getting downsized.

Expand full comment

The competition is fierce these days. :)

Expand full comment

Mine had 46. There could have been 50 but 4 girls dropped out of school between 10th and 12th grades because they were pregnant and so therefore undeserving of education. For those not running the numbers, that was almost 20% of the girls.

Expand full comment

That twit Kevin Sorbo left a tweet showing 4 leaders who had their political opponents arrested. He named Stalin, Hitler, Mao and Biden.

Uh no, Jerkules. Trump did HIMSELF in with his own actions. Biden had absolutely nothing to do with TFGs legal woes. Oh, and the 4 you mentioned are believers in God. Just like you.

Expand full comment

How short their memories are. Trump tried desperately to have Ms. Clinton arrested.

Expand full comment

I don't think he actually tried, that would have taken effort. He certainly talked about it a lot, knowing that's what his people wanted to hear.

Expand full comment
Jun 11, 2023·edited Jun 11, 2023

They've stopped uttering "But her emails!" and are now fixated on "Hunter Biden's laptop!"

With the GQP, the title changes but the song remains the same.

Expand full comment

I still haven't figured out what they think is on that laptop. But it reminds me of an Uber a few weeks ago in Vegas. The guy had Sean Hannity on the radio, barely had the AC on, and took the longest possible route to my destination. 20 minutes of listening to that jerk make vague allusions.

Expand full comment

Maybe they think Hillary's emails are on his laptop.

Expand full comment

With whoever* it was they were waiting for.

* Can't recall his name just that he is dead.

Expand full comment

You talking about John Paul Mac Isaac?

Expand full comment

The song is ended. but the malady lingers on.

Expand full comment

I like the way Bowling for Soup put it. "Same Song, Different Chorus"

Expand full comment

"You take a look around

And you say 'hey, wait!'

This is the same as

Where I just came from

I thought it was over

Oh, that's just great!"

- Bowling for Soup

Expand full comment

Where was Kevin Yobbo when Trump led his supporters in chants of "Lock her up"?

Expand full comment

Interesting. A local RWNJ posted a comment to that same effect. Makes me wonder if they all independently have the same stupid ideas or if they all blindly repeat stupid ideas they’ve seen elsewhere.

Expand full comment

Blindly repeat stupid ideas they’ve seen elsewhere.

A lot of the times it starts as Russian propaganda, then gets picked up by RWNJ "news".

Expand full comment

Collective dead brain.

Expand full comment

That's why one of my favorite questions to ask consewertives over at the TBT was, "Did your parents have any children that were not brain dead at birth?"

Expand full comment

The one I heard as a kid was "Did your parents ever have any children that lived?"

Expand full comment

TBT?

Expand full comment

Tampa Bay Times.

Expand full comment

Thank you.

Expand full comment

Seems like they all read from the same badly-written script.

Expand full comment

Maybe someone stole ChatGPT 1.0.

Expand full comment

They've been Borg'd.

Expand full comment

Or assassinated, at least for Stalin (Trotsky).

Show me Biden's "rehabilitation"/goulag/concentration/death camps too.

Expand full comment

Rohm and the purge of Nazi leaders, via Hitler ("Night of the Long Knives").

Expand full comment
Jun 11, 2023·edited Jun 11, 2023

In case no one's heard, Ted "Unabomber" Kaczynski has died.

How about that? A free bunk space in prison for Trump has just opened up.

Expand full comment

First Trump, and now this. Good times.

Expand full comment

Good times, any time you meet a payment,

Good times, Any time you feel free . . . .

I just dated myself.

Expand full comment

I dated myself once. We went out for pizza and split the cheque.

Then we came back home and fucked like rabbits.

Expand full comment

I hope you didn't forgot to use a condom.

Expand full comment

Nice Catholic boys would never use those evil things.

Expand full comment

Nice Catholic boys aren't supposed to be dating their hand either.

Expand full comment

She probably thought she was smarter than drumpster when she just copied the document.

Expand full comment

She has the right to remain silent. What she lacks is the capacity.

Expand full comment